Skip to content
Ashley Rawlins Esq., A.k.a. Car Crash Ash® | Experience the Ashley Advantage
English | Español Call Ash! 24/7 858-529-5872
Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys Logo
  • Practice Areas
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Rideshare Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Catastrophic Injuries
    • Traumatic Brain Injury
    • Slip and Fall Accidents
    • Dog Bite Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
  • About Us
    • About Rawlins & Meet Our Team
    • Media
    • Case Results
    • Community
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Locations
    • San Diego
    • Chula Vista
    • Escondido
    • Riverside
    • San Bernardino
    • Sacramento
  • Contact
  • Search
Experience the Ashley Advantage

Can a Car Accident Claim Be Reopened?

Home  ► Blog  ►  Can a Car Accident Claim Be Reopened?

August 23, 2023 | Ashley Rae Rawlins
Can a Car Accident Claim Be Reopened?

After a car accident, you often focus on recovering from your injuries, repairing vehicle damage, and getting your life back on track.

You may need to file an insurance claim or lawsuit. Receiving a settlement provides the necessary compensation for medical treatment and daily living.

Despite your best efforts, you may realize that your settlement will not cover your costs. This situation can leave you wondering whether you can reopen a car accident claim. In this situation, a San Diego car accident lawyer can help you reopen your car accident claim.

Understanding the Finality of Settlements

Settling a car accident claim is a relief after a stressful process. This conclusion offers closure. Legally speaking, settlements are final; they close the door to future claims on the same incident. The law, however, acknowledges exceptions to this rule.

Given the complexities of personal injury law and the various factors in each case, involve a competent lawyer to analyze your legal situation and advise on the best course of action.

  • The finality of settlements: Settlements in personal injury cases, including those involving car accidents, are usually final. This ensures an end to litigation, and both parties have closure. Once you sign a settlement agreement, you typically give up your right to bring further claims regarding the same accident.
  • Insurance policies: The insurance policy can influence the reopening of a claim. Some have specific provisions or exclusions on additional claims following a settlement. Your lawyer can examine your policy to understand its possible implications.
  • Exceptions to the finality rule: There are circumstances under which you can reopen a claim. These exceptions vary by jurisdiction and individual case details, making it essential for a lawyer to examine your situation.
  • How a lawyer can help: A lawyer has an in-depth understanding of the law and experience in similar cases. Your lawyer will analyze your case, advise you on potential exceptions, and go through the complex process of arguing for an exception to the finality rule.

Timing and Reopening a Claim

The time elapsed since your settlement significantly affects the feasibility of reopening your claim. Each jurisdiction has a statute of limitations—a legal time limit within which you must take a particular action. An experienced lawyer can explain these time limits and how they apply to your case.

Understanding the finality of settlements and their exceptions is a good starting point for reopening a car accident claim. This complex process requires a clear understanding of the law.

Types of Settlements

Understanding the types of settlements typical in personal injury cases is crucial. Lump sum settlements involve a one-time payment that covers all damages, while structured settlements feature multiple payments over a period. The type of settlement could influence the possibility and process of reopening your claim.

Grounds for Reopening a Car Accident Claim

Discovering new information after settling a car accident claim can be distressing. Perhaps your injuries led to further medical complications, or you discovered additional damage to your vehicle that wasn't initially apparent. These circumstances might leave you questioning whether you can reopen your claim.

The following section will discuss potential grounds for reopening a claim. It will also demonstrate how a lawyer is instrumental in interpreting these grounds and evaluating their applicability to your situation.

New Medical Conditions or Additional Damage 

In some cases, you might discover new injuries or damages from the accident after authorities settle the claim. These new findings could provide grounds for reopening your claim, but it's a matter of complex legal interpretation.

Car accidents can result in long-term consequences, such as chronic pain, long-term disability, and psychological trauma. If you develop such issues that your initial car accident settlement did not account for, you might have grounds to reopen your claim.

Legal Implications

The discovery of new medical conditions or additional damage may change your situation significantly. While your condition is a sufficient testament to your suffering, proving its connection to the accident and the need for additional compensation is not straightforward.

Legal Support

A knowledgeable lawyer's input is invaluable. They will determine whether the newly discovered information aligns with the legal grounds for reopening a claim. They will interpret your circumstances with your best interests in mind. Your lawyer can navigate the complexities of personal injury law to reopen your claim.

The Process of Reopening a Claim

Reopening a car accident claim is complex and differs by case. It involves several stages, including application, representation, and negotiation or potential court action.

Reopening a claim involves legal fees and court costs. It would be best to account for these expenses before deciding to proceed. Many personal injury lawyers work on a contingent fee basis, meaning you only pay if they win your case.

The following describes the process of reopening a claim, which your lawyer will navigate.

Car Accident

Application to Reopen the Claim

The first step is making an application. This application must present compelling reasons to justify reopening the case—such as new evidence or a change in circumstances. Your lawyer will correctly formulate and appropriately file your application.

Representation and Negotiation

If authorities accept your application, your lawyer may start renegotiating with the other party's insurance company or preparing for a court hearing. Your lawyer will represent you, protect your interests, and argue for the best possible outcome.

Potential Court Proceedings

The case may proceed to court if negotiations fail to reach an agreeable conclusion. Your lawyer will prepare your case thoroughly, gather the necessary evidence, and represent your best interests in the courtroom.

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is a process that helps resolve disputes without going to court. You can use ADR to resolve various disputes involving personal injury law.

ADR includes mediation, arbitration, and negotiation. In mediation, a neutral third party helps the parties to settle. The mediator does not have the power to decide for the parties but can help them to communicate and understand each other's points of view.

Arbitration involves the parties agreeing to have a neutral third party decide their dispute. The arbitrator has the power to make a binding decision. In negotiation, the parties try to settle on their own with or without the help of a neutral third party.

ADR can take less time and money than going to court. It is also more private and less adversarial. ADR is usually a more flexible process than going to court. The parties can agree on the rules and procedures to resolve the dispute. This process can help if the parties have different ideas about resolving the conflict.

Mediation or arbitration may be viable alternatives if the legal process of reopening a claim becomes challenging. These dispute-resolution methods offer a less formal and often quicker way to resolve disagreements. They still need the consent of both parties involved.

The process may differ significantly depending on the case's specific circumstances and jurisdiction. Hiring an attorney is crucial to understand the specifics of your case.

Potential Complications and Challenges

Reopening a car accident claim involves navigating a complex legal landscape with numerous technicalities and possible setbacks. What follows are some common challenges and examples of how a lawyer can tackle them and mitigate any potential complications.

Legal Challenges

The law contains intricate details requiring careful interpretation and execution. From arguing against the finality of the initial settlement to proving the need for additional compensation, the journey includes potential legal obstacles.

Mitigating Complications

Practical complications can arise in reopening your claim. These may include gathering new evidence, dealing with resistant insurance companies, or managing public perception. Your lawyer can strategize to handle these issues effectively while protecting your rights and advocating for your interests.

The potential complications and challenges in reopening your car accident claim can be daunting. A competent lawyer can guide you through this process, mitigating issues and standing by your side every step of the way. Having highlighted the process of reopening a claim and its challenges, we will now focus on the lawyer's role.

The Role of a Lawyer

Lawyers play an invaluable role in reopening your car accident claim. From providing much-needed guidance to representing your interests and navigating potential challenges, a lawyer's involvement can mean the difference between a negative and positive outcome for your case.

Your lawyer will take on many tasks, including:

  • Gathering evidence: Your lawyer will identify, collect, and organize the evidence to support your application to reopen your claim. This evidence may include additional medical reports, repair cost estimates, and expert testimony.
  • Handling negotiations: Negotiating with insurance companies can be challenging. Insurers may resist revisiting a settled claim. Your lawyer will handle these negotiations.
  • Representing your interests in court: If your claim ends up in court, your lawyer will prepare your case and represent you in the best possible manner, arguing your position and striving for a favorable ruling.

Enlisting a lawyer's services can make a significant difference. Their knowledge, experience, and commitment can provide crucial guidance and support through this complex process.

Get the Legal Help You Need to Reopen Your Car Accident Claim

ASHLEY RAE RAWLINS
Ashley Rae Rawlins, Car Accident Lawyer in San Diego

Navigating the complexities of reopening a car accident claim can be overwhelming. The process features intricate legal details, potential obstacles, and significant challenges. As daunting as these aspects may seem, having a skilled lawyer can make a substantial difference.

Your lawyer will guide you through these complexities and the intricacies of your case. From collecting the necessary evidence and formulating and filing an application to negotiating on your behalf and representing you in court if required, your lawyer will be with you at every step of this journey. They will defend your rights, advocate for your interests, and strive toward achieving the best possible outcome.

Remember that each case is unique. There is no universal solution or timeline—it depends on your circumstances. Hiring a seasoned lawyer can provide much-needed peace of mind during this challenging time.

Ashley Rae Rawlins Author Image

Ashley Rae Rawlins

Founder and CEO - Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys, APC

Personal Injury Attorney

Author's Bio

Contact Us 24/7 For A Free Case Evaluation

Call Ash!
Stacy Quichocho

"I truly can’t say thank you enough to Ashley and her team. This was unfortunately the 2nd time I had to reach out to Rawlins Law for their services after being rear ended again. Fortunately though, I knew exactly who to call as soon as it happened. I was confident in knowing that I would be provided the best fight and settlement with Car Crash Ash on my side! Ashely is a thorough and steadfast attorney. The team was great and Amy was communicative and professional in aiding us through the process. My family and I are so grateful for Rawlins Law! Thank you Ashley, Amy and team for fighting for us so resolutely! We will recommend it to you time and time again!"

Becky Rivera

"After being involved in my first accident, I had no idea what to do or who to call. Thankfully a friend of mine recommended Car Crash Ash & they helped me out tremendously. I absolutely appreciate Belen for all she has done and kept in contact with me during the entire process. Thank you! I will recommend this place to everyone."

Mike Kelley

"I wish I could give this review 10 stars! In August of 2022 I got rear ended on the freeway. My car was totaled and I ended up in the ER with severe neck pain. A friend recommended I call the Rawlins Law Firm. He raved about the service and said I would be in good hands. HE WAS RIGHT! Ashley and the team were kind, sympathetic, got me the right medical treatment and communicated with me every step of the way. But, make no mistake here. Ashley is a bit down and never let go of the tenacious bulldog when it comes to dealing with insurance companies. She has a very intimate knowledge of how insurance companies work and she doesn't take no for an answer. After all was said and done she got all the medical bills paid and got me a very large lump sum settlement. If you're ready for this, take my word for it. Car crash Ash is the real deal!"


Free Case Evaluation 24/7
We Are Here For You!
Call Me Now!


Free Case Evaluation!


Chula Vista
333 H St, Suite 5000,
Chula Vista, CA 91910
(619) 815-5629

Escondido
500 La Terraza Blvd, Suite 150,
Escondido, CA 92025
(760) 437-2495

Sacramento
500 Capitol Mall #2350,
Sacramento, CA 95814
(916) 502-9879

Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys
San Diego
3511 Camino Del Rio S, 5th Floor Room #3,
San Diego, CA 92108
(858) 529-5872

Mailing Address: 3111 Camino Del Rio North Suite 400,
San Diego, CA 92108

Riverside
11801 Pierce Street, Suite 200,
Riverside, CA 92505
(951) 400-4724

San Bernardino
473 E Carnegie Dr,
San Bernardino, CA 92408
(909) 530-3095

Orange
1100 West Town & Country Rd., Suite 1250,
Orange, CA 92868
(714) 725-8949

Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys footer logo
  • Practice Areas
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact
  • Sitemap
© 2025 Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys - Car, Truck & Motorcycle Personal Injury Lawyer | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms