Truck accidents caused by distracted driving can leave victims facing significant physical, emotional, and financial challenges. Proving negligence in these cases often requires a deep understanding of how the law applies to distracted driving and the unique elements that set these accidents apart from other motor vehicle collisions. When you work with a truck accident lawyer, you gain an advocate who can focus on key evidence and build a compelling case to establish fault.
Understanding Negligence in Truck Accidents
Negligence occurs when a person or entity fails to act in a way that a reasonable person would under similar circumstances, resulting in harm to others.
In the context of truck accidents, distracted driving often constitutes negligence because truck drivers must exercise extreme caution due to their vehicles' massive size and power. When drivers divert their attention from the road, whether by texting, eating, or adjusting a GPS device, they place others at risk.
To prove negligence in a truck accident, your truck accident lawyer must establish four primary elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages. The truck driver’s duty involves operating their vehicle safely and responsibly. If they breach that duty by engaging in distracted driving, and that breach directly causes an accident that results in harm, then negligence can be established. Each element requires compelling evidence to ensure your claim is as strong as possible.
Uncovering Evidence of Distracted Driving
Proving that a truck driver was distracted during the accident often requires uncovering evidence supporting this claim. Cellphone records are among the most critical forms of evidence in these cases.
How an Attorney Obtains Phone Records
A truck accident lawyer can work to subpoena the driver’s phone records to determine whether they were texting, calling, or using apps during the moments leading up to the crash. These records can provide a timeline of activity, indicating whether the driver was distracted.
Once the subpoena is issued, the phone company must provide the requested records, including timestamps of calls, texts, and data usage. This information allows your lawyer to build a timeline of the truck driver’s activities. For example, if the records show the driver sent a text just moments before the crash, it strengthens the argument that distraction played a significant role in the accident.
Other Evidence
In addition to phone records, your truck accident attorney may seek supporting evidence, such as dashcam footage or eyewitness testimony, to corroborate distracted driving claims. Combining these pieces of evidence helps create a compelling case that holds the negligent driver accountable, increasing the likelihood of a favorable outcome for your claim.
Reviewing this footage can reveal whether the driver’s eyes were on the road or looking elsewhere. Video evidence can also capture behaviors such as reaching for an object or engaging in other distractions.
Eyewitness testimony can further support a claim of distracted driving. Passengers, other drivers, or pedestrians who witnessed the accident may provide accounts of the truck driver’s actions. For instance, if a witness saw the driver holding a phone or looking away from the road, this testimony can help establish that distraction was a factor in the crash.
Leveraging Technology to Prove Negligence
Technology is pivotal in proving negligence in truck accidents involving distracted driving. In addition to cellphone records and dashcam footage, trucks are often equipped with electronic logging devices (ELDs) and black boxes that record data about the vehicle’s operation. These devices can provide information about the truck’s speed, braking patterns, and the driver’s hours of service leading up to the accident.
The “Black Box”
A truck’s black box, also known as an event data recorder, can show whether the driver tried to brake or swerve before the crash. A lack of response may suggest that the driver was not paying attention. Similarly, data from ELDs can reveal whether the driver complied with federal regulations regarding rest breaks. Fatigue combined with distraction can significantly impair a driver’s ability to react to hazards on the road.
Technology can also be used to reconstruct the accident. Accident reconstruction experts often use data collected from the scene and information from black boxes to create simulations of the crash. These simulations can illustrate the sequence of events and highlight how distracted driving contributed to the collision.
Liability Beyond the Driver in Distracted Driving Truck Accidents
Determining liability in distracted driving truck accidents can involve looking beyond the driver's actions. While the truck driver may appear to be the primary party at fault, there are often other responsible entities whose negligence contributed to the accident. Identifying these parties is vital for ensuring victims receive the full compensation they deserve.
Trucking Company Accountability
Trucking companies play a significant role in creating and enforcing policies that promote safe driving practices. If a trucking company fails to implement or enforce policies discouraging distractions, they might share liability. For instance, companies that pressure drivers to meet unrealistic delivery schedules can create an environment where distractions are more likely to occur.
To prove the company’s responsibility, your attorney will investigate internal records, such as employee training materials and dispatch communications, to uncover evidence of negligent policies or practices.
In addition, if a trucking company didn’t provide their fleet with hands-free technology or failed to monitor compliance with federal safety regulations, they could be held accountable. These failures can create conditions where distracted driving becomes a higher risk. By examining the company’s policies, technology usage, and safety protocols, your lawyer can build a case demonstrating the company’s role in contributing to the accident.
Third-Party Liability
Liability in truck accidents can also extend to third parties, such as maintenance providers or equipment manufacturers. For example, if a faulty GPS system distracted the driver at a critical moment, the system’s manufacturer may bear some responsibility. Similarly, if improper maintenance by a third-party repair company led to malfunctioning equipment that caused the driver to divert their attention from the road, that company could also be held liable.
Uncovering third-party liability requires a thorough investigation into the circumstances of the crash. Your attorney will analyze maintenance records, inspect the vehicle, and review the design and functionality of the equipment involved to determine if any external factors contributed to the driver’s distraction. Your truck accident lawyer will pursue every avenue for compensation, maximizing the chances of a favorable outcome for your case.
Using Federal Regulations to Strengthen Your Case
Truck drivers and trucking companies are subject to federal regulations designed to ensure the safety of all road users. Truck drivers can’t text or use handheld devices while driving, per FMCSA (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration) rules. Violating these regulations is not only illegal but also provides evidence of negligence.
A truck accident attorney can use violations of FMCSA rules to bolster your case. For instance, if phone records indicate the driver was texting, this violation strengthens the argument that they breached their duty of care. Similarly, records showing that the driver exceeded hours-of-service limits can demonstrate that fatigue played a role in the accident, compounding the effects of distraction.
Federal regulations also require trucking companies to implement safety programs and monitor driver compliance. A company failing to uphold these responsibilities can face significant liability. Your attorney will explore whether violations of federal rules contributed to the accident and use this information to support your claim.
Establishing Causation in Distracted Driving Cases
Proving causation is a critical step in establishing negligence. Even if you can demonstrate that the driver was distracted, you must also show that their distraction directly caused the accident and your injuries. Causation often hinges on connecting the driver’s behavior to the events leading up to the crash.
Physical evidence from the scene can be instrumental in proving causation. Skid marks (or a lack thereof), vehicle damage, and debris patterns can reveal how the accident unfolded. For example, if there are no skid marks, it could suggest that the driver didn’t attempt to stop, which aligns with a claim of distraction. In addition, analyzing the point of impact can help determine whether the driver’s inattention caused them to veer into another lane or fail to react to slowing traffic.
Medical records also play a role in establishing causation. Your injuries must be directly linked to the accident to secure compensation. Detailed documentation from healthcare providers can demonstrate how the crash caused your injuries and the extent of the harm you’ve suffered. This evidence is essential in proving that the accident – not another event – led to your damages.
Demonstrating Damages After a Truck Accident
Once you’ve established that distracted driving caused the accident, you must also prove the extent of the damages you’ve suffered. Damages can include medical expenses, lost income, property damage, and pain and suffering. Gathering evidence to document these losses is important to building a strong claim.
Medical records, bills, and receipts provide concrete evidence of the financial impact of your injuries. Your truck accident lawyer may also work with medical professionals to assess your long-term needs, such as ongoing treatment or rehabilitation. These assessments help ensure that you seek compensation that reflects the full scope of your losses.
Lost income and diminished earning capacity are other significant components of damages. Pay stubs, tax returns, and employer statements can help demonstrate the income you’ve lost due to the accident. If your injuries prevent you from returning to your previous line of work, your attorney may calculate the value of your reduced earning potential to account for future losses.
Challenging Defenses in Distracted Driving Cases
Insurance companies often try to shift blame away from the truck driver or trucking company. Anticipating these defenses and preparing to counter them is essential to proving negligence. One common tactic is to argue that external factors, such as weather or road conditions, were the primary cause of the accident. Your lawyer can use evidence from the scene and expert testimony to refute these claims.
Another defense involves questioning the validity of your evidence. For example, an insurer might argue that cellphone records don’t definitively prove distraction or that dashcam footage is inconclusive. Your truck accident attorney can address these challenges by presenting additional evidence that supports your claim, such as witness testimony or accident reconstruction findings.
Insurance adjusters may also attempt to downplay the severity of your injuries or suggest that pre-existing conditions contributed to your suffering. Medical records and testimony from healthcare providers can help counter these arguments by demonstrating how the accident caused or worsened your injuries. Your lawyer will ensure that your evidence is presented in a way that strengthens your case and undermines the insurer’s attempts to reduce your compensation.
Reasons to Act Fast
Time is critical when pursuing a truck accident claim involving distracted driving. Evidence can quickly disappear, and witnesses may forget the details or decide they no longer want to be involved in your case. Acting promptly to gather evidence and build your case is essential to proving negligence.
Your truck accident lawyer can take immediate steps to preserve evidence, such as sending spoliation letters to the trucking company. These letters demand the company retain relevant records, including black box data, maintenance logs, and driver logs. Failing to preserve this evidence can result in legal consequences for the company and bolster your claim.
Acting quickly also ensures you comply with the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury claim. Missing this deadline can bar you from recovering compensation, no matter how strong your case may be. Your attorney will work to file your claim within the required timeframe and keep your case on track.
Legal Representation Matters, Call a Truck Accident Attorney
Proving negligence in a truck accident involving distracted driving can be complex. However, having a truck accident lawyer on your side ensures that you have someone dedicated to protecting your rights and pursuing the compensation you deserve. They aim to secure a resolution that reflects the full extent of your losses and holds the responsible parties accountable for their actions.
A truck accident lawyer has the skills and resources to investigate the circumstances of your crash and present a compelling case for compensation. Working with legal counsel gives you the best chance of achieving a favorable outcome and moving forward after a devastating accident. Contact a personal injury attorney for a free case review as soon as possible.
Ashley Rae Rawlins
Founder and CEO - Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys, APC
Personal Injury Attorney
Author's Bio