When Is the Trucking Company Liable?

When Is the Trucking Company Liable?

Accidents involving large commercial trucks can be devastating, often causing severe injuries, property damage, and even fatalities. After an accident, it's natural to wonder who must pay for the damage and whether you can hold the trucking company liable.

The best way to find out who you can hold liable for your accident is to discuss your case with a San Diego truck accident lawyer as soon as you can.

Schedule A Free Case Evaluation Today!

Understanding Trucking Company Liability

Trucking companies must follow strict regulations set by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to ensure the safety of their vehicles and drivers on the road.

These regulations cover everything from driver qualifications and training to vehicle maintenance and cargo securement. A trucking company that fails to adhere to these standards may bear liability for any resulting accidents.

You can hold a trucking company responsible for an accident in several ways:

Negligent Hiring and Training

Trucking companies are legally obligated to ensure their drivers are qualified, competent, and properly trained to drive safely. This process begins with hiring, where companies must conduct thorough background checks on potential drivers. 

These checks should include reviewing the driver's criminal history, driving record, and employment history. Companies should also verify that the driver holds a valid commercial driver's license (CDL) and has the necessary endorsements for the type of vehicle they will operate.

Once hired, drivers must receive comprehensive training on the specific vehicles they will be driving, safe driving practices, defensive driving techniques, and proper cargo securement. This ongoing training should include regular refresher courses to ensure drivers stay up-to-date on the latest safety regulations and best practices.

If a trucking company fails to conduct proper background checks, hires drivers with a history of reckless behavior or safety violations, or does not provide adequate training, you can hold it liable for any accidents caused by its drivers.

In such cases, the company's negligence in hiring and training practices directly contributes to the accident, making it responsible for the resulting damages and injuries.

Inadequate Vehicle Maintenance

Proper vehicle maintenance is the key to ensuring the safety of commercial trucks on the road.

Trucking companies must maintain their fleets in accordance with federal and state regulations and manufacturer guidelines. This includes regular inspections, preventive maintenance, and timely repairs of any defects or worn parts.

Brake systems, tires, steering components, and lighting systems are among the most critical areas that require regular attention. Brake failures, tire blowouts, and other mechanical issues can lead to devastating accidents, particularly given the size and weight of commercial trucks.

Trucking companies must keep detailed records of all maintenance and repair work performed on their vehicles. These records can demonstrate compliance with safety regulations and identify potential issues before they cause accidents.

If a trucking company fails to properly maintain its vehicles and an accident occurs, you can hold the company liable for negligence. Victims of such accidents may recover compensation for their injuries, medical expenses, lost income, and other damages.

Overloading or Improperly Securing Cargo

Proper loading and cargo securement are essential for the safe operation of commercial trucks. Overloading a truck can cause various problems, including reduced braking efficiency, increased stopping distances, and decreased stability. 

This can make the vehicle more difficult to control, particularly in emergencies or adverse weather conditions.

Improperly secured cargo can also pose significant risks. If cargo shifts during transit, it can cause the truck to become unbalanced, increasing the likelihood of a rollover accident. Unsecured cargo can also fall from the vehicle, creating hazards for other motorists.

Trucking companies must ensure their vehicles adhere to appropriate weight limits and that FMCSA regulations adequately secure all cargo. These regulations specify the types of tie-downs, straps, and other securement devices that truckers must use and the minimum number of tie-downs required based on the cargo's weight and length.

If a trucking company allows its vehicles to be overloaded or fails to ensure proper cargo security, you can hold it liable for any resulting accidents. This includes accidents caused by the truck's instability or falling cargo that strikes other vehicles or pedestrians.

Encouraging or Allowing Unsafe Driving Practices

Trucking companies are responsible for promoting and enforcing safe driving practices among their drivers.

This includes ensuring that drivers adhere to hours-of-service regulations and limiting the time a driver can spend behind the wheel without rest. These regulations aim to prevent fatigued driving, significantly increasing the risk of accidents.

However, some trucking companies may prioritize profits over safety, encouraging or pressuring their drivers to meet unrealistic delivery deadlines. This can lead to drivers engaging in unsafe practices such as speeding, driving for longer hours than allowed, or preceding necessary rest breaks.

Additionally, trucking companies must not tolerate or encourage other reckless behaviors such as distracted driving, driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol, or aggressive driving. Companies should have clear policies that prohibit these behaviors and outline the consequences for violating these policies.

If a trucking company encouraged or allowed unsafe driving practices that contributed to an accident, you can hold the company liable. This is true even if the driver directly caused the accident, as the company's policies and practices created an environment that encouraged or enabled unsafe behavior.

Victims of accidents caused by unsafe driving practices can seek compensation from the driver and the trucking company. An experienced truck accident lawyer can help investigate the company's policies and practices to determine if they contributed to the accident and hold them accountable for their negligence.

Proving Trucking Company Liability

If you've been involved in an accident with a commercial truck and believe that the trucking company may be liable, it's important to gather as much evidence as possible to support your claim.

This can include:

Police Reports and Accident Scene Photographs

Police reports, and accident scene photographs are key pieces of evidence in any trucking accident case. When an accident occurs, law enforcement officers will respond to the scene and create an official report detailing their observations and findings.

This report will include information such as the accident's date, time, location, parties involved, injuries or fatalities, and a description of the vehicle damage.

The police report may also include statements from the drivers, passengers, witnesses, and the officer's opinion on the cause of the accident. This information can be valuable in determining fault and liability.

In addition to the written report, police officers or accident investigators will often take photographs of the accident scene. These photographs can provide visual evidence of the damage to the vehicles, the position of the vehicles after the truck accident, skid marks, road conditions, and other relevant details.

These photographs can help accident reconstructionists piece together how the accident occurred and identify any contributing factors.

Witness Statements

Witness statements can provide valuable insight into how a trucking accident occurred. Bystanders or other motorists who witnessed the accident can describe what they saw, including the truck driver's actions, any unusual or reckless behavior, and the sequence of events leading up to the collision.

These statements can help corroborate other evidence and provide a more complete picture of the accident. They can also be particularly useful in cases where the truck driver's account of the accident differs from that of the victim or other witnesses.

It's important to collect witness statements as soon as possible after the accident while the events are still fresh in their minds. A truck accident attorney can assist in identifying and interviewing potential witnesses and securing their statements for use in the case.

The Truck Driver's Qualifications and Training Records

The qualifications and training of the truck driver involved in an accident can play a significant role in determining liability. Trucking companies must ensure that their drivers are properly licensed, trained, and qualified to operate their assigned vehicles.

Reviewing the driver's qualifications and training records can reveal important information, such as:

• Whether the driver possessed a valid CDL at the time of the accident
• Whether the driver had any prior accidents, traffic violations, or license suspensions
• Whether the driver had completed the necessary training and certifications for the type of vehicle they were operating
• Whether the driver had received adequate training on safe driving practices, defensive driving, and proper cargo securement

If the driver's records reveal any deficiencies in their qualifications or training, or if the trucking company failed to properly vet the driver before hiring them, this can serve as evidence of negligence on the company's part.

The Truck's Maintenance and Inspection Records

Proper maintenance and regular inspections are essential for ensuring the safe operation of commercial trucks. Trucking companies must keep detailed records of all maintenance and inspection work performed on their vehicles.

These records can provide valuable insight into the truck's condition during the accident and whether any mechanical issues may have contributed to the collision.

Some key things to look for in maintenance and inspection records include:

• Regular oil changes, tire rotations, and brake inspections
• Repairs or replacements of worn or damaged parts
• Any recurring issues or problems with the vehicle
• Records of annual inspections and any violations or out-of-service orders
• Compliance with manufacturer-recommended maintenance schedules

If the records show that the trucking company failed to properly maintain the vehicle or address known issues, this can provide evidence of negligence in an accident case.

The Truck's Cargo Manifest and Loading Documents

Transporting cargo can play a significant role in commercial truck accidents. Overloaded or improperly secured cargo can shift during transit, causing the truck to become unstable and increasing the risk of a rollover or other serious accident.

The truck's cargo manifest and loading documents can provide important information about the contents of the trailer, including:

• The type and quantity of cargo present 
• The weight and distribution of the cargo
• The method used to secure the cargo
• Any special handling or transportation requirements for the cargo

Reviewing these documents can help determine whether the truck was overloaded or if the cargo complied with federal regulations regarding proper securing. If the trucking company or its employees failed to follow proper loading procedures, this can serve as evidence of negligence in an accident case.

Data from the Truck's Electronic Logging Device (ELD) or Black Box

Many commercial trucks have electronic logging devices (ELDs) or black boxes that record information about the vehicle's operation. This information can provide insight into the truck's speed, braking, and other factors that may have contributed to an accident.

Some key information obtained from an ELD or black box includes:

• The truck's speed at the time of the accident and in the moments leading up to it
• Whether the driver applied the brakes before the collision
• The number of hours the driver had been on duty and behind the wheel
• Any sudden changes in speed or direction that may indicate evasive maneuvers or loss of control

This data aids in reconstructing the accident and identifying potential violations of hours-of-service regulations or other safety rules. It can also help determine whether the driver's actions contributed to the accident or if other factors, such as mechanical issues or road conditions, played a role.

A trucking accident attorney can help obtain and interpret this data as part of a comprehensive investigation into the cause of the accident and the potential liability of the trucking company and its driver.

Contact a Truck Accident Lawyer

If you or a family member suffered an injury in a trucking accident, don't wait too long to seek the help of an experienced attorney.

Contact a knowledgeable trucking accident lawyer today to discuss your case and learn more about your legal options. With a truck accident attorney by your side, you can pursue the justice and compensation you deserve.