Did you recently suffer harm in a car accident that wasn’t your fault? If so, you might wonder whether contacting your insurance company is the right move. Here’s what you need to know about reporting a not-at-fault accident to your provider—and why you should hire a car accident lawyer to do it for you.
Schedule A Free Case Evaluation Today!
Do Insurance Companies Need to Know About Every Accident?
After a car accident, you might wonder whether you should inform your insurance company, especially if you believe you’re not at fault. In most cases, the answer is yes – you should notify them, but you might want a lawyer to do it.
First, your insurance policy likely contains a clause requiring you to promptly report all accidents, regardless of fault. Most auto insurance policies include this type of requirement. Failure to report per the terms of your policy could lead to complications if you later decide to file a claim. Immediately reporting the accident ensures that you adhere to your policy’s terms and conditions.
Second, even if you think the other driver is clearly at fault, there’s no guarantee their insurance will cover all your medical expenses and other losses. The insurer might dispute the claim, or the other driver might not carry enough insurance. In such situations, you might need to rely on your own insurance for coverage, especially if you have uninsured or underinsured motorist protection.
Finally, providing a timely account of the accident to your insurer gives them a chance to start their investigation early. This early involvement can prove crucial if you file a claim and legal disputes arise later on.
So, while it might seem tempting to bypass your insurer when you’re not at fault, notifying them about every accident remains a wise choice. But a lawyer can do this without creating any problems with your claim.
Should I Notify My Insurance if I’m Not at Fault for the Accident?
Yes. Even if you’re certain another party caused the accident, report the incident to your insurer.
By notifying your insurance company promptly, you preserve your right to claim the benefits and protections available under your policy. If the other driver’s insurance doesn’t cover your claim or disagreements arise concerning liability, your insurance can act as an essential safety net.
Moreover, the other driver could later decide to file a claim against you, accusing you of causing the accident. If this occurs, your prompt reporting places your insurer in a stronger position to defend you, as they have immediate access to all the relevant details of the accident.
Tips for Reporting an Accident to Your Insurance Company When You’re Not at Fault
Insurance adjusters have a wealth of experience in handling accident claims, which can place the uninformed driver at a disadvantage, even if they’re not at fault. You must approach these conversations with preparation and awareness to maximize your compensation and protect your rights throughout the process.
Below are some essential tips to keep in mind when you’re reporting a not-at-fault accident to an insurance representative.
Seek Legal Representation Before You Begin or as Soon as Possible After
Having a legal representative on your side early in the process makes a significant difference.
Lawyers possess in-depth knowledge about the nuances of insurance claims. They can guide you on what to say, what not to say, and how to protect your rights. With a lawyer, you have the added assurance that you’re making the right moves, not mistakes that could hurt your claim.
Get the Adjuster’s Name and Contact Details
At the beginning of every interaction, ask the adjuster for their details. When you have their name and contact information, you can reach out directly regarding any updates, concerns, or questions.
It also promotes accountability on the adjuster’s part, allowing you to document with whom you spoke and when. These details can prove useful if any disputes arise down the line.
Stay Calm and Courteous
A composed demeanor sets a positive tone for discussions with the adjuster. By remaining calm and polite, you foster an atmosphere of cooperation, ensuring that your interactions remain focused on resolution. Moreover, a courteous approach often makes adjusters more inclined to assist, reducing potential conflicts and facilitating smoother negotiations.
Limit the Information You Provide About the Accident
Be clear and concise in your descriptions. Providing brief, factual information reduces the risk of misunderstandings.
Overloading an adjuster with unnecessary details can muddle the core facts, giving them potential avenues to challenge or minimize your claim. By remaining clear and to the point, you ensure that the central facts of your case stay at the forefront.
Stick to the Facts of the Accident
Avoid speculation or guessing about anything when you discuss the accident with the adjuster, as this could be detrimental to your claim. If you don’t know the answer to a question from the adjuster, simply admit you don’t know and move on.
The insurance company could exploit any deviations from factual data later on, potentially citing discrepancies to discredit or challenge your account of the accident.
Do Not Admit Fault or Liability
Any admission, even a slight one, could have profound effects on your claim. Insurance companies are always looking for ways to minimize payouts. By admitting fault or liability, even in passing, you might provide them with the ammunition they need to reduce or outright deny your compensation.
Do Not Provide a Recorded Statement Without Preparation or Legal Advice
Never provide recorded statements for insurance claims. Insurance adjusters can review and analyze these recordings repeatedly, seeking any discrepancies or admissions they can use against you.
Document Your Conversations With the Adjuster
Keep track of the date, time, and details of each interaction with the insurance adjuster. A comprehensive record of all communications builds a robust trail of evidence.
You may need this evidence if any disputes arise about what you or the adjuster said. Documenting dates, times, and content ensures you have a valuable resource for any future challenges.
Remember You May Decline to Speak Until You’re Ready
Rushing into discussions can lead to oversights or mistakes. Keep in mind that you always have the right to take a step back, gather your thoughts, and prepare adequately. By choosing when to engage with the insurance adjuster, you ensure you approach conversations from a position of readiness, clarity, and strength.
Does My Insurance Cover Me if the Accident Wasn’t My Fault?
Possibly. Different insurance policies provide different types of coverage, so your ability to claim compensation from your own insurer will depend on the specifics of your policy.
Most states require drivers to carry liability insurance. Liability insurance covers the other party’s medical expenses and damage to their property if you’re at fault for an accident. So, in an accident where you’re not the responsible party, this coverage won’t pay for your own damages.
Personal injury protection (PIP) and medical payments (MedPay) coverage cover medical expenses and, in some cases, lost income, no matter who is at fault for the accident. However, PIP is not available and MedPay is optional in most states. You can’t rely on PIP except in a no-fault state, and you can’t use MedPay unless you chose to pay extra in premiums to add it to your policy.
Uninsured (UM) and underinsured (UIM) motorist protection are optional in most states. If the at-fault driver lacks insurance or has insufficient coverage to pay for your losses, these insurance riders can cover your medical and property repair costs.
Collision coverage is another optional type of insurance that protects you no matter who causes the accident. If another driver hits your vehicle, collision coverage can pay for your car’s repairs. If the other driver caused the accident and has adequate insurance, their insurance should cover your expenses. But if it doesn’t, your collision coverage can kick in to make up the difference.
What Happens if I Don’t Report a Not-At-Fault Accident?
Choosing not to report a not-at-fault accident to your insurance company might seem like a straightforward way to avoid paperwork and potential premium hikes. However, this decision has numerous potential risks and consequences.
First, just because you believe you’re not at fault doesn’t guarantee the other party sees it the same way. They might report the accident and claim you were the responsible party. If they do this and you haven’t reported the accident, you’re on the back foot. You lose the proactive advantage of having your insurer’s awareness and support from the onset.
Furthermore, your injuries or damage might not always be immediately apparent. You might think there’s just minor damage to your car, only to discover more significant issues later on. Or, what might feel like a slight ache could evolve into a severe medical concern. If you haven’t reported the accident, seeking compensation for these late-appearing problems becomes more challenging.
Most insurance policies also include a clause requiring policyholders to report all accidents promptly. If you fail to do so, your provider will likely see this as a breach of your policy terms. This breach could lead to complications if you later decide to make a claim or even result in a denial of coverage.
Last, not reporting the accident could complicate matters if legal actions arise. Having a documented report with your insurer provides a record of the incident, which is often valuable in defending your position if you go to court.
Will My Rates Go Up if I Report a Not-At-Fault Accident?
One of the most common concerns drivers have after an accident is the potential effect on their insurance premiums, even when they’re not at fault. Whether your rates will go up after reporting a not-at-fault accident depends on several factors.
Most states have regulations in place that prevent insurance companies from raising rates for accidents where the policyholder wasn’t at fault. These rules keep drivers from suffering financial penalties for incidents beyond their control.
However, if you have multiple not-at-fault accidents in a short period, insurance companies might see you as a high-risk driver. They might argue that while you did not cause these accidents, the frequency suggests you might put yourself in risky situations. In such cases, your rates could increase.
Your policy’s specific details and your insurance company’s practices could also play a role. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness with their policies, ensuring that your first accident, whether you’re at fault or not, doesn’t affect your rates.
Always review your policy and your state’s regulations with a knowledgeable attorney to understand the potential implications of an accident on your rates.
Do I Need a Lawyer if I Suffer Injuries in a Not-At-Fault Accident?
Suffering injuries in a car accident that you didn’t cause brings up numerous questions, one of the most pressing being, “Do I need a lawyer?”
Even if you are clearly not at fault for the accident, work with a personal injury attorney because:
- A Lawyer Can Negotiate on Your Behalf: Insurance companies, even your own, always aim to minimize payouts. A skilled attorney can negotiate with insurance adjusters on your behalf, demanding a fair settlement that covers your medical expenses, lost income, and any pain and suffering.
- Your Attorney Can Determine Liability and Present a Strong Case: Determining liability isn’t always clear-cut. The other party’s insurance might dispute the claim, arguing that you share some or all of the blame. An attorney can gather evidence, consult experts, and build a strong case that establishes the other driver’s fault.
- Your Lawyer Can Calculate the Full Value of Your Claim: Some crash injuries have long-term implications that aren’t immediately evident. With a lawyer’s guidance, you can account for future medical treatments, rehabilitation, and any long-term care needs when seeking compensation.
- An Attorney Can Handle Your Claim While You Focus on Recovery: Dealing with insurance claims, medical bills, and legal proceedings while recovering from injuries is often overwhelming. Having an attorney handle all these aspects of your claim allows you to focus on your recovery.
Ashley Rae Rawlins
Founder and CEO - Rawlins Law Accident & Injury Attorneys, APC
Personal Injury Attorney
Author's Bio